Part II: Reviews of 1892
The Daily Chronicle, 23 May 1892
"Mr. Wilde's Whim," The Daily Chronicle, Monday, 23 May 1892, p. 3. Review of Wilde's Poems (Sixth edition, 1892). Attribution based on Karl Beckson, The Oscar Wilde Encyclopedia (New York: AMS Press, 1998), p. 193.
He who would make paradoxes must first make his life a paradox. The last whim in Mr. Wilde's consistent inconsistency is to republish his poems. No hand, he sings somewhere in the present volume, can gather up the fallen withered petals of the rose of youth. Therefore, he gathers them — into a sixth edition. Then, too, as we know, Mr. Wilde has not for some time had a good word to say for verse. The modern literary art — has he not told us in prose. "Dionysiac and red-veined"? — is prose. Can it be that Mr. Wilde has republished his poems to prove it? We can hardly, however, deem him guilty of so prosaic an intention as the wish to prove anything. It is probably his quite perverse sense of humour that has dictated the freak. One can be too earnest even about French prose. And then Mr. Wilde, we fancy. is one of the few heroes who have a humorous appreciation of their shadows. He loves to lead them a dance, to watch their imitative contortions. How good it is to hear the parasite, with his perplexed intelligence — "By the mass, and 'tis like a camel, indeed." Then, too, these shadows alternately interest and bore him. Therefore he loves at once to attract and elude them, for he has one objection to the flattery of imitation, its proverbial sincerity. These fellows mean it all so. For him life is a kaleidoscope, the chameleon's dish. His mind is the eternal flux of Heraclitus, "all life is one, and all is change.
There are other indications of the eternal flux about this reissue than its re-publication. Though there are no new poems, it is considerably more than a mere new edition. It were better described as a transmigration, for it is the old soul in a splendid new body. Whether it is transmigration up or down we won't venture to say. By a wonderful new binding, designed by Mr. Ricketts, Mr. Wilde has contrived to bring his new poems up to date, his past into harmony with his present, without the alteration of a single line. This mere binding speaks more than the complete works — say, of Mr. Lewis Morris. Once, ah! it was dear innocent apple-blossom artlessly printed in the gold of a maiden's hair, on a ground of white vellum, white as a maiden's chastity: now it is a strange dream of quivering heliotrope flecked with bars of gold. Had we the art to reckon our thrills, we might devote a column to describing our sensations from this binding. Messrs. Elkin Mathews and John Lane are already distinguished for the format of their publications, but certainly they quite surpass their reputation in the vesture of the present volume. One is tempted at the moment to declare it the most beautiful, as certainly it is the most sumptuous, cloth binding we have seen. The end-papers are a cunning variation on the design of the cover, and the delicious mannered title-page is faced by a quaint certificate of the limitation of issue (220 copies), to which Mr. Wilde has appended his autograph — audacious as the long amber shoots of the bramble.
If, without offence, one may suggest that the binding has any significance apart from its beauty, we find it, as we hinted above, in the fact that, to our mind, it supplements the poems, bridges the time 'twixt 1882 and 1892. In the early editions the binding was an accompaniment. In the present it is a commentary. It is the first binding. we might say, grown ten years older. And one applies it thus: You read an eagle-eyed sonnet on Milton or Liberty, a simple Requiescat on a young maid, a fiery religious ecstasy, and all seems strange, a little irreconcilable, till you look at the binding and are reminded that "all life is one and all is change":
And so from hour to hour we ripe and ripe,
And then from hour to hour we rot and rot,
And thereby hangs a tale.
It has been the custom to smile at Mr. Wilde's poems. Certainly he set the fashion himself, as he also taught his critics the trick of those epigrams which immediately go off when one ventures to claim for his poems a little of that serious hearing which paradoxes and such toys apart, they deserve. "They suggest incorrect quotations from Swinburne and Rossetti," says one critic smartly enough, though had his reading extended to Matthew Arnold, Milton, Shakespeare, Keats, and indeed Mr. Wilde knows who, he might just as pertinently have included them among Mr. Wilde's creditors. But then, in literature who does not know that such "conveyancing" is but a question of stealing from thieves. And, granting that there are no few lines in Mr. Wilde's poems that "had elsewhere their setting," no person in earnest about his pleasures will deny that the volume, as a whole, gives one a sense of a new personality. Indeed, to us, it is a curious fact that a book so full of echoes should bring so unmistakeable an impression of an original temperament. Mr. Wilde is certainly more original in his "quotations" than most people are in their "originality." The impressionability of the artist's nature could hardly have a more complete Protean expression. "A stringed lute on which all winds can play," so he describes himself. His very indeterminateness of character becomes a characteristic. What Mr. Pater calls the "one desperate effort to see and touch," the passion to taste all exquisite experience, spiritual and sensual — that is life as Mr. Wilde realises it, and this book of poems is one of the parti-coloured records of it all. But all, from the heroism to the honey, is, at least in that tranquil remembrance of which Wordsworth speaks, seen to have been experienced from the epicurean standpoint. It has been lived for the thrill of it, "like the thistledown that hath no seed," leaving behind it nothing of the bias, but only the colour of experience. At the time, of course, the emotion was real enough, how else could it have been emotion? There were no doubt moments as when, for instance, he had just put down Carlyle's account of the taking of the Bastille, in which Mr. Wilde would feel capable of taking his place side by side with those "Christs that die upon the barricades"; moments when in reading of the Bulgarian massacres he might have a momentary feeling of real concern "lest Mahomet be crowned instead of Thee!" moments when in reading the "Apologia" he could, like Villon, write a sonnet to the Virgin; moments when, remembering such emotions, he might even persuade himself that —
Surely there was a time I might have trod
The sunlit heights, and from life's dissonance
Struck one clear chord to reach the ears of God.
We are prepared to understand that Mr. Wilde still believes that he did really once possess that "ancient wisdom and austere control," for which he sighs his "Hélas!"
But let us quote the whole sonnet, which is of Mr. Wilde's best —
To drift with every passion till my soul
Is a stringed lute on which all winds can play,
Is it for this that I have given away
Mine ancient wisdom, and austere control?
Methinks any life is a twice-written scroll
Scrawled over on some boyish holiday
With idle songs for pipe and virelay,
Which do but mar the secret of the whole.
Surely there was a time I might have trod
The sunlit heights, and from life's dissonance
Struck one clear chord to reach the ears of God:
Is that time dead? lo! with a little rod
I did but touch the honey of romance —
And must I lose a soul's inheritance?
What a pity that it should he only a mood! Yet one would have to be surer of that "ancient wisdom and austere control" before saying more. Besides, is it not, after all, the fate of the artist, like Mr. Stevenson's Sons and Daughters of Joy, to "pass on" — if he is to escape a wearisome reproduction of himself? So we behold Mr. Wilde in these poems passing on from faith to faith, from love to love, all to the same end, as the bee from flower to flower — to hive experience in honeycombs of verse.
To say that Mr. Wilde is Protean is, of course, to say that he is an artist. But we insist on it, because, perhaps more than any Englishman, he is the very embodiment of the type. We fancy he is absolutely without feelings or aims of any kind unconnected with art. Life is to him what Mr. Whistler's mother (or should we say the portrait of his mother) is to that artist, a certain arrangement of form and colour; or rather a chaos of form of colour, a palette, a vocabulary. In his absolute worship of beauty Mr. Wilde, we fancy, would need to alter even Keats' catholic statement. He would hardly say, "Beauty is truth, truth beauty." Why drag in truth? Beauty is beauty —
.... that is all
Ye know on earth and all ye need to know.
For, sweet, to feel is better than to know,
And wisdom is a childless heritage,
One pulse of passion — youths' first fiery glowó
Are worth the hoarded proverbs of the sage:
Vex not thy soul with dead philosophy,
Have we not lips to kiss with, hearts to love, and eyes to see!
One distinctive quality, over and above its sensuous passion, Mr. Wilde's verse — and, indeed, all his work — possesses, the artist's definite memory for the forms of things. We cannot recall any English writing, save the poetry of Keats, which is so full of fine detail. Even the abstract comes to Mr. Wilde in concrete images, and he knows to a shade the colour of everything he sings of. This is, of course, always significant of an entirely artistic nature. Take these two verses, for example, chosen at random from that o'er sweet pageant of "Charmides":
Through the grey willows danced the fretful gnat,
The grasshopper chirped idly from the tree,
In sleek and oily coat the water-rat
Breasting the little ripples manfully
Made for the wild-duck's nest, from bough to bough
Hopped the shy finch, and the huge tortoise crept across the slough.
On the faint wind floated the silky seeds,
As the bright scythe swept through the waving grass,
The ousel-cock splashed circles in the reeds
And flecked with silver whorls the forest's glass,
Which scarce had caught again its imagery
Ere from its bed the dusky tench leapt at the dragonfly.
We don't quote this as anything very fine, but simply to illustrate the fact that Mr. Wilde's poems are no mere effusions of either fleshly or abstract passion, as has been imagined, but have this much claim as art — that they are based on the careful garnering of beautiful facts. Indeed, we think that in his many delicious pictures of English meadow scenery Mr. Wilde is at his best. Could anything be more delicious than these verses from "Panthes," a poem rapturously celebrating the materialistic idea of the hereafter —
.... that grand living after death
In beast and bird and flower —
which, if it owes dues to Mr. Swinburne, can, we think, afford to pay them:
O think of it! we shall inform ourselves
Into all sensuous life. The goat-foot Faun.
The Centaur, or the merry bright-eyed Elves
That leave their dancing rings to spite the dawn
Upon the meadows, shall not be more near
Than you and I to nature's mysteries, for we shall hear
The thrush's heart beat, and the daisies grow,
And the wan snowdrop sighing for the sun
On sunless days in winter: we shall know
By whom the silver gossamer is spun,
Who paints the diapered fritillaries,
On what wide wings from shivering pine to pine the eagle flies.
We have hinted that Mr. Wilde's passion is not merely sensuous. That he can be heroic as well as dainty, witness this very Wordsworthian sonnet to Milton:
Milton! I think thy spirit hath passed away
From these white cliffs, and high embattled towers;
This gorgeous fiery-coloured world of ours
Seems fallen into ashes dull and grey,
And the age changed unto a mimic play
Wherein we waste our else too-crowded hours:
For all our pomp and pageantry and powers
We are but fit to delve the common clay,
Seeing this little isle on which we stand,
This England, this sea-lion of the sea,
By ignorant demagogues is held in fee,
Who love her not: Dear God! is this the land
Which bare a triple empire in her hand
When Cromwell spake the word Democracy!
Hear the conclusion of the whole matter:
I have made my choice, have lived my poems, and,
Though youth is gone in wasted days.
I have found the lover's crown of myrtle
Better than the poet's crown of bays.
We think that there will be a leaf or two of laurel among the myrtle.
* Poems by Oscar Wilde. New Edition, 220 copies, 200 for sale. (London: Mathews and Lane.)
Notes: Sir Lewis Morris (1833-1907) was a popular Anglo-Welsh poet. A single volume collection of his works was first published in 1890.
Related Material
- Introduction to Le Gallienne's Reviews of Wilde, with contents list
- Le Gallienne's (and others') reviews of Wilde's The Sphinx
Created 13 November 2026