rchitecture was widely written about as well as practised.in the Victorian period. At the most scholarly level, it became a subject for research, systematization and debate, attracting some of the ablest minds of the time — including leading practitioners. The rise of antiquarianism, the Gothic Revival, the spread of empire, and the development of architecture and civil engineering as professions, all contributed to this development..
Antiquarianism goes back at least to John Leland (c.1503-1552), already at work in the libraries of religious houses before their dissolution, and Nicholas Brigham (d.1558), who erected Chaucer's tomb in Poet's Corner, Westminster Abbey. Other landmarks in its history are William Camden's Annales (1615 onwards); Sir William Dugdale's tour de force, the Monasticon Anglicanum (3 volumes, 1655-73), a direct response to the destruction of that "stupendious number of Monastick Foundations ... the continued work of many Ages, by which the greatest Kings, Princes,and Noblemen of this Island were once thought to have eternized their names" (Letter to William Bromley, Esq.); and John Aubrey's Chronologia Architectona (1671) in Part IV of his Monumenta Britannica (see Fox). By 1751 there was enough interest in the subject for a Royal Charter to be granted to the already well-established Society of Antiquaries.
A typical page from John Collingwood Bruce's book on Hadrian's Wall, The Roman Wall: A Description of the Mural Barrier of the North of England, 10.
From around the turn of the eighteenth century, the term "antiquarianism" appears regularly, to denote a popular gentleman's pursuit: the Newcastle Antiquarian Society, the first such society in the provinces, was founded in 1813. John Collingwood Bruce (1805-1892), with his special interest in Hadrian's Wall, became first a fellow of the London society, then the secretary and vice-president of the Newcastle one. By 1833, the third item in the Gentleman's Magazine's classification of its contents, after the more wide-ranging categories of reviews and "dissertations," is "The Antiquities and Architecture of Great Britain and Ireland, including Topography and Family History; with original documents illustrative of these several subjects" (last page). Notice the coupling of "antiquities " and "architecture" here, as in the title of the "Architectural and Historical Society of Oxford," founded in 1839 — although here architecture takes precedence.
The Gothic Revival, with its roots in the pre-Romantic and Romantic period, encompassed religious feeling as well a sense of history, and was later motivated by it. The Cambridge Camden Society, called after William Camden, and also founded in 1839, was impelled more by dissatisfaction with the current state of the church than by an interest in the Gothic for its own sake. Its fundamental aim, and that of the Ecclesiological Society that succeeded it, was to revive older forms of worship in the Church of England. Nevertheless, it had a direct and enormous impact on the study of architecture, by sending people out to look at churches and record their features, and prescribing the way in which old Anglican churches and cathedrals should be restored, and new ones built. Tellingly, the Cambridge Antiquarian Society, set up in 1840, was a quite separate group.
The Taj Mahal (from a photograph). One of the illustrations in James Fergusson's extraordinarily comprehensive A History of Architecture in All Countries, VII: 596.
Interest in different forms of Gothic led many to explore Europe: one of the influences behind the Cambridge Camden Society, for instance, was William Whewell (1794-1866), the Master of Trinity College, whose Architectural Notes on German Churches, with Remarks on the Origin of Gothic Architecture, had been published in 1830, and came out in a much enlarged edition in 1842. Robert Willis (1800-1878), often thought of tas the "father" of architectural historians, published his Remarks on the Architecture of the Middle Ages, especially of Italy in 1835. Others were soon exploring the furthest reaches of empire with the same fascination. The prime example here is James Fergusson (1808-1886), who, having gone out to Calcutta as a partner in his brother's indigo firm, published his Rock-Cut Temples of India in 1845, and went on to write the first history of world architecture, published from 1865 onwards. David Watkin describes him as covering "an astonishingly wide variety of periods and countries" (82), while Nikolaus Pevsner calls him "the leading English architectural historian of these years" (237).
Those for whom architecture was a vocation or a trade also had energetic and passionate spokesmen, none more fervent than Augustus Welby Pugin, whose highly influential Contrasts (1836) has been described as the "first architectural manifesto" (Hill). Other prominent architects like Sir George Gilbert Scott also spared time to express their views, engaging in "The Battle of the Styles" verbally as well as through competitions and in their draughtsmanship. Architectural pundits like Alexander Beresford Hope emerged and took leading roles at the now "Royal" Institute of British Architects. Famous figures in the closely allied world of civil engineering were raising its profile by their feats as well: without actually reading or publishing any papers, Brunel received an honorary degree from Oxford in 1857. The specialised outlets for discussions of their works were thriving. Apart from RIBA's Transactions there were the Architectural Magazine, founded by J. C. Loudon as early as 1834, the Civil Engineer and Architect's Journal, first published in 1837, and The Builder in 1843. The Architectural Association, founded in 1847, not only provided training for young architects, but a forum for talks by notables like Ruskin and Scott.
With the appointment of Banister Fletcher as Professor of Architecture and Building Structure at King's College, London, in 1890, architecture came of age as an academic subject. The professor fitted out a display room wiht his photographs of world architecture and other study materials, and set about compiling a new architectural history. Written with his son, Sir Banister Flight Fletcher, this late Victorian tome is regularly updated and has never been out of print. In the preface to the fifth edition, Banister Flight Fletcher (who was later knighted) wrote: "Architecture has been described very truly as the printing press of all ages, and it appears possible that in these days of enlightenment the study of Architectural History will soon take its proper place as part of a liberal education" (viii). It is no fault of the nineteenth century that this optimism has only proved partly justified.
Architectural Historians and Theorists of the Victorian Period (Selected and Annotated)
- Thomas Rickman (1796-1841): "An Attempt to Discriminate the Styles of English Architecture from the Conquest to the Reformation" (1815, published as a book in 1817, last ed., 1881). This milestone publication established the terms for the three phases of Gothic as Early English, Decorated and Perpendicular.
- William Whewell (1794-1866): Architectural Notes on German Churches, with Remarks on the Origin of Gothic Architecture (1830, much enlarged third ed., 1842). These "Notes," not to mention their Master's enthusiasm for architecture, helped inspire his students to form the Cambridge Camden Society.
- Robert Willis (1800-1878): Remarks on the Architecture of the Middle Ages, especially of Italy (1835); "On the Construction of Vaults in the Middle Ages" (1842). Pevsner describes this as "epoch-making" because of its "standard of insight and meticulous accuracy" (54). David Watkin calls Willis "probably the greatest architectural historian England has ever produced" (65).
- Rev. John Louis Petit (1801-1868): Remarks on Church Architecture (2 vols. 1841); Remarks on Architectural Character (1846); Architectural Studies in France (1854); Architectural Principles and Prejudice (1854). Not scholarly enough for Pevsner, Petit's commentaries are nevertheless interesting to him, revealing their author to be "an eclectic in tolerating all available styles (100).
- James Fergusson (1808-1886): A History of Architecture in All Countries (4 vols. 1865-76). This ambitious enterprise was the first of its kind, and the summation of a lifetime's intense study and categorizing of, and writing about, architecture. "His passion is system-building," says Pevsner (238), but Fergusson could be very shrewd, as Kenneth Clark acknowledges in citing his comments on Pugin's theatricality (121).
- Sir George Gilbert Scott (1811-1878): A Plea for the Faithful Restoration of Our Ancient Churches (1850, includes more general remarks); Remarks on Secular and Domestic Architecture, Present and Future (1858); Lectures on the Rise and Development of Medieval Architecture (2 vols. 1879). Like Scott's auto biography, these are key documents for those interested in this influential figure.
- A. W. N. Pugin (1812-1852): Contrasts (1836); The True Principles of Pointed or Christian Architecture (1841, coincidentally, the same year as the first volume of The Ecclesiologist appeared); The Present State of Ecclesiastical Architecture in England (1843); An Apology for the Revival of Christian Architecture in England (1843). James Stevens Curl talks of the "zeal (even fanaticism) Pugin brought to his arguments" in favour of fourteenth-century Gothic (39). As a result, there is no substitute for reading Pugin in his own words — which, thanks to the Internet Archive, is now perfectly feasible. Contrasts is not there yet, but is available as a free book in Google Books.
- John Ruskin (1819-1900) The Seven Lamps of Architecture (1848); Stones of Venice (2 vols. 1851-53); Lectures on Architecture and Art (1853). "Here he was wholly influenced by Pugin; his hysterical denial proves it" (Pevsner 141). Curl calls both Ruskin and Pugin bigots, and suggests that "'Ruskinian influences were coincident on changes of taste that were occurring already" (49). Obviously these are topics for discussion.
- Edward Augustus Freeman (1823-1882): A History of Architecture (1848); An Essay on the Origins and Development of Window Tracery in England (1850-51, based on lectures given at the Oxford Architectural Society, see Watkin 74).
- Banister Fletcher (1833-1890): A History of Architecture for the Student, Craftsman, and Amateur, being a Comparative View of the History of Styles from the Earliest Period (1896; with his son, Banister Flight Fletcher). Many excerpts from the enlarged 5th edition of this work can be found in the Victorian Web.
- John Willis Clark (1833-1910) The Architectural History of the University and Colleges of Cambridge (1886). A mammoth undertaking, begun by his uncle Robert Willis (see above)
- William Morris (1834-1896) "The Prospects of Architecture in Civilization" (1881) in Hopes and Fears for Art (1882). Pevsner finds Morris "monumentally inconsistent" in the views expressed in his short pieces and various comments, but sees in him "the consummation of the Gothic Revival and especially of Ruskin" (viii).
- Charles Eastlake (1836-1906): A History of the Gothic Revival (1872). "No student of 19th-century architectural thought can ignore it, limited though it be" writes John Steegman. It was "deliberately limited," he explains, "because its author wrote with the unshakeable assumption that Revived Gothic, whether English, French or Italian in its derivation, was the only true national form of architecture for England" (300). Many extracts from this too can be found on the Victorian Web.
- George Gilbert Scott, Jnr (1839-1897): An Essay on the History of English Church Architecture prior to the Separation of England from the Roman Obedience (1881). Writing some years later, Scott, in contrast to Eastlake, favoured the Queen Anne style.
- J(ohn) Alfred Gotch (1852-1942): Architecture of the Renaissance in England (2 vols. 1891-94); Early Renaissance Architecture in England (1901). Gotch was President of the Architectural Association in 1866-67 and would later be President of RIBA (1923-5). Another architect-historian, his work like the younger Scott's reflected the swing towards the style of these periods.
- Reginald Blomfield (1856-1942): The Formal Garden in England (1892); developed and extended in History of Renaissance Architecture in England, 1500-1800 (2 vols. 1897). These were just the earlier books of this nephew of Sir Arthur Blomfield, whose writings like Scott Jnr's and Gotch's were based on his own practice, and who (like the former) particularly liked the period of Sir Christopher Wren. He believed Richard Norman Shaw "could alone claim" to carry his mantle (Turnor 104, though Turnor himself disagrees). Blomfield would become President of RIBA earlier than Gotch, in 1912.
- William Lethaby (1857-1931): Architecture, Mysticism, and Myth (1891); Medieval Art, from the Peace of the Church to the Eve of the Renaissance, 312-1350 (1904). The former was "widely read in the 1890s by those interested in mysterious, organic and symbolic design" (Watkin 89), such as Charles Harrison Townsend, and the latter represents a culmination of the interest in the relationship between eastern and western art.
Pugin's St Giles, Cheadle (1841-46), from his The Present State of Ecclesiastical Architecture in England, Plate IV.
- Architectural Books, and Professional and Trade Journals (a general discussion)
- Architectural Trades and Professions
- Medieval English Gothic Architecture: Backgrounds to the Gothic Revival (excerpts from Banister Fletcher)
- The Gothic Revival
- The Cambridge Camden Society and the Ecclesiological Society
- James Fergusson, Architectural Historian
- Victorian Doubt, Victorian Architecture, and the Battle of Styles
- Katherine Wheeler's Victorian Perceptions of Renaissance Architecture (review)
- Ruskin and the Arts
- Morris's Medievalism
Bruce, John Collingwood. The Roman Wall: A Description of the Mural Barrier of the North of England 3rd ed. London: Longmans, Green, Reader, and Dyer, 1867.
Clark, Kenneth. The Gothic Revival. Harmondsworth: Penguin (Pelican), 1964.
Curl, James Stevens. Victorian Architecture. Newton Abbot: David & Charles, 1980. Print.
Fergusson, James. A History of Architecture in All Countries. London: Murray, 1876. Internet Archive. 14 February 2012
Fletcher, Banister F. Preface to the Fifth Edition. A History of Architecture on the Comparative Method for the Student, Craftsman, and Amateur. By Banister Fletcher and Banister F. Fletcher 5th ed., revised and enlarged. London: Batsford, 1905. vii-viii. Internet Archive. Web. 14 February 2012.
Fox, Adam. "Aubrey, John (1626-1697)." Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. Online ed. Web. 14 February 2012.
Gentleman's Magazine. Vol. 1 (1834), New Series. Hathi Trust (from the Princeton Library). Web. 14 February 2012.
Hill, Rosemary. "Greek Temples in Crowded Lanes: Pugin in the Strand." Talk at King's College, London. 13 February 2012.
Letter to William Bromley, Esq. (initialled J. W.), prefacing Monasticon Anglcanum, or the Histories of Ancient Abbeys, and Monastries, Hospitals, Cathedral and Collegiate Churches in England and Wales, with Divers French, Irish, and Scotch Monastries formerly belonging to England. English ed. London: Sam Keble, 1893. Internet Archive. Web. 14 February 2012.
Pevsner, Nikolaus. Some Architectural Writers of the Nineteenth Century. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1972. Print.
Pugin, A. W. N. The Present State of Ecclesiastical Architecture in England. "Republished from the Dublin Review." London: Charles Dolman, 1843. Print.
The Society of Antiquaries of Newcastle upon Tyne: History of the Society. The Society's website. Web. 13 February 2012.
Steegmann, John. A Study of the Arts and Architecture from 1830 to 1870. Paperback ed. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1971. Print.
Turnor, Reginald. Nineteenth Century Architecture in Britain. London: Batsford, 1950. Print.
Watkin, David. The Rise of Architectural History. London: Architectural Press, 1990. Print..
Last modified 1 December 2014